Premier League · Matchweek 9

Brighton's extra goals bought 4 points. Forest's misses cost almost 10.

Brighton have scored and saved 13 goals more than their chances were worth, but most came in blowouts, so it bought only about 4 points. The luck that moves the table is at the bottom, where Forest are almost 10 points short.

Brighton's extra goals bought about 4 points; Forest are almost 10 short

Brighton's extra goals bought about 4 points; Forest are almost 10 shortPoints against expected-goals difference for all 20 Premier League teams. Arsenal (24 points, +7.3), Brighton (19, +3.8) and Chelsea (16, +0.9) sit above the typical line. Nottingham Forest (6 points, +4.5), Manchester United (7, +2.1) and Sunderland (5, -0.8) sit far below it.-10-50+5+10+100510152025typical points for the chancesMore points than chancesFewer points than chancesQuality of chances: created minus allowed, in goalsPointsMan City: 21 pts, xG difference +7.7, goal difference +10Liverpool: 15 pts, xG difference +3.0, goal difference +2Brentford: 14 pts, xG difference +2.1, goal difference +7Bournemouth: 12 pts, xG difference +4.9, goal difference +1Tottenham: 12 pts, xG difference +1.6, goal difference 0Aston Villa: 12 pts, xG difference -5.9, goal difference -3Hull City: 11 pts, xG difference -4.4, goal difference +1Leeds: 11 pts, xG difference -0.9, goal difference +1Newcastle: 11 pts, xG difference -5.3, goal difference -2Ipswich: 11 pts, xG difference -5.3, goal difference -4Everton: 10 pts, xG difference -2.7, goal difference -1Fulham: 9 pts, xG difference +3.6, goal difference -2Coventry: 9 pts, xG difference -6.1, goal difference -7Crystal Palace: 7 pts, xG difference -10.3, goal difference -12Arsenal: 24 pts, xG difference +7.3, goal difference +9Brighton: 19 pts, xG difference +3.8, goal difference +17Chelsea: 16 pts, xG difference +0.9, goal difference +4Man United: 7 pts, xG difference +2.1, goal difference -5Nottm Forest: 6 pts, xG difference +4.5, goal difference -6Sunderland: 5 pts, xG difference -0.8, goal difference -10Arsenal 24 ptsBrighton 19 ptsChelsea 16 ptsMan United 7 ptsNottm Forest 6 ptsSunderland 5 pts
Each crest is a team after 9 games (Newcastle and Everton 8). The dashed line is the points teams usually get from chances like theirs.
All 20 teams as a table
TeamPtsGoal diffChances diff (xG)Goals vs chancesProj. pts
Arsenal24+9+7.3+1.782
Man City21+10+7.7+2.377
Brighton19+17+3.8+13.269
Chelsea16+4+0.9+3.160
Liverpool15+2+3.0−1.060
Brentford14+7+2.1+4.958
Bournemouth12+1+4.9−3.957
Tottenham120+1.6−1.653
Aston Villa12−3−5.9+2.945
Hull City11+1−4.4+5.445
Leeds11+1−0.9+1.949
Newcastle11−2−5.3+3.346
Ipswich11−4−5.3+1.344
Everton10−1−2.7+1.747
Fulham9−2+3.6−5.650
Coventry9−7−6.1−0.939
Man United7−5+2.1−7.145
Crystal Palace7−12−10.3−1.731
Nottm Forest6−6+4.5−10.545
Sunderland5−10−0.8−9.238

Brighton are this season's giant killer, Luis Paez-Pumar argued at Defector on Nov. 2, after Saturday's 1-0 win at Manchester City left them with "a stranglehold on third place." He granted that they've been "somewhat over-performing" their expected goals, 24 scored from chances worth about 17.

That undersells it. Count both ends and Brighton have scored and saved 13 goals more than their chances were worth, the second-biggest start in Europe's big five leagues over two seasons. But it bought them only about 4 points, because most of it came in blowouts. The luck that moves the Premier League table is at the bottom, where Nottingham Forest are almost 10 points short of what their chances usually earn.

The goals

Brighton's extra goals came when the game was already won

Brighton built most of the gap in three routs: 5-0 at Coventry, 3-0 over Arsenal and 5-0 over Crystal Palace. Their chances in none of those games were worth more than 2.5 goals. A fourth or fifth goal helps goal difference but doesn't add a point.

Brighton's gap grew in blowouts; Forest's slid almost every week

BrightonNottingham Forest
Brighton's gap grew in blowouts; Forest's slid almost every weekBrighton's line rises to +13.2, with big jumps in a 5-0 win at Coventry, a 3-0 win over Arsenal and a 5-0 win over Crystal Palace. Forest's line falls almost every week to -10.5.-10-5051015Game 1Game 5Game 9goals match chancesBrightonForest
Each dot is one match, in order.

The luck that did pay came Saturday. City made chances worth about two goals to Brighton's one, and Bart Verbruggen made seven saves to keep the 1-0. He has saved about 4.5 more goals than the shots he's faced usually allow, a third of Brighton's gap. Three own goals in their favor add 2 more.

Brighton's gap is more than double anyone else's

Goal difference minus what each team's chances deserved. Top six and bottom five.

Strip that out and Brighton are still good: 5th in the chances they make and allow, before and after accounting for who they've played. Teams like that usually have about 15 points after nine games; Brighton have 19. Arsenal have actually gained more points from luck, about 6.5, through tight wins like Sunday's 1-0 at Liverpool.

The points

Forest are where the points went missing

Bill Connelly at ESPN filed Forest under "good, but unlucky" last week: "The fundamentals are in great shape." Oliver Glasner says the start "feels unfair", and NBC's Nicholas Mendola has them "almost 10 full goals behind their xG." The points are the bigger story. Forest make and allow chances like the league's 4th-best team and have 6 points, almost 10 fewer than that usually earns. No big-five team in two seasons started that far short; the closest, 2025-26 Wolves, were 8.8 points short.

  • They've scored 6 goals from chances worth almost 15, and none at home. Only 1 in 5 of their shots hits the target, the league's worst, and Liam Delap has 1 goal from 24 shots.
  • Man United (17th) and Sunderland (20th) are each about 7 points short. United lead the league in shots (163), mostly without striker Benjamin Sesko, out since Sept. 16. Connelly calls Sunderland "bad, but unlucky."
Will it last?

Hot and cold finishing evens out fast

Teams that finish way above or below their chances early don't keep doing it. Across 192 team seasons in Europe's big five leagues, the hot and cold finishers after 9 games were both back to normal the rest of the way. Making good chances carried over; finishing them didn't.

Hot and cold finishers were back to normal after game 9

Goals per game better (+) or worse (-) than the chances. Big-five leagues, 2024-25 and 2025-26.
  • Points fell back too. Hot starters dropped from 1.78 a game to 1.44; cold starters climbed from 0.75 to 1.10.
From here

Brighton hold 3rd; Forest and United should stay up

We played out the last 29 games from each team's points and chances so far, using those same 192 seasons.

Forest and United are headed for about 45 points; Brighton hold 3rd

Projected share of the remaining points (50% = 1.5 points a game). The band is the typical miss, about 9 points.
  • Brighton have about a 60 to 70% chance at the top four. Forest and Man United both land around 45 points, each with roughly a 1-in-5 chance of going down.
  • Sunderland end up around 38, with roughly a 40 to 50% chance of going down.

Next up: Forest host Man City on Nov. 7. On Nov. 8, Brighton host Brentford, Sunderland host Chelsea and Man United host Aston Villa, who visit Barcelona in the Champions League. More in our Premier League predictions.

FAQ

Questions people ask

Are Brighton for real in 2026-27?

Their place is; their goal difference isn't. Brighton have scored and saved 13 goals more than their chances, mostly in blowouts, so it added only about 4 points. We have them finishing 3rd.

Why are Nottingham Forest in the relegation zone?

They can't finish. Forest have scored 6 goals from chances worth almost 15, none at home, and have almost 10 fewer points than chances like theirs usually earn.

Will Manchester United be relegated?

Probably not. United are 17th in the table but 9th in the chances they make and allow. Snapp AI has them around 45 points with roughly a 1-in-5 chance of going down.

Does outscoring your xG last in soccer?

Mostly no. In Europe's big five leagues, teams far above or below their expected goals (xG) after 9 games were back to normal afterward. Making good chances carried over; finishing didn't.

How we did this

Snapp's soccer warehouse (Sportmonks xG and expected goals on target), Premier League matches through Nov. 1, 2026 (89 of 90 matchweek 1-9 games; Newcastle vs Everton on Nov. 2 not included). "Chances" means expected goals (xG). Chance difference = team xG minus opponent xG. Goals vs chances = goal difference minus xG difference; it counts own goals as goals, and own goals carry no xG. Points versus chances use the typical-points line from the same big-five sample (points per game = 1.367 + 0.709 x xG difference per game): Brighton +4.0, Arsenal +6.5, Man United -6.8, Sunderland -6.7, Forest -9.5. Of the 192 past team seasons, the furthest below that line after 9 games was Wolves 2025-26 (-8.8). Goalkeeper figures compare expected goals on target faced with non-own-goal goals allowed. Brighton's 13.2-goal gap breaks down as saves +4.5, opponents missing the target +2.8, Brighton's finishing on target +2.6, own goals +2.0 and shot placement +1.4. Carryover tests and the projection use 192 team seasons from the Premier League, La Liga, Bundesliga, Serie A and Ligue 1 in 2024-25 and 2025-26 (first 9 games vs the rest). Goals minus xG over the first 9 games had a 0.08 correlation with the rest of the season (about +/-0.14 at 95%, since only two seasons of xG exist per league); xG difference carried at 0.75, goalkeeping at -0.09 and shot accuracy at 0.20. Projection: rest-of-season points per game = 1.007 + 0.269 x points per game + 0.343 x xG difference per game (R-squared 0.58; typical miss 0.30 points a game, about 9 points over 29 games). Probabilities come from a 200,000-run simulation that treats teams as independent and ignores fixtures, injuries and transfers, so read them as rough; ranges cover the base run, a 30% wider miss and projections shrunk 20% toward average. Schedule adjustment adds the average xG difference of each team's opponents; after it, Arsenal rank 1st, Brighton 5th, Forest 6th, Chelsea 7th, Man United 8th and Sunderland 10th. Injury lists as of Nov. 1. xG models differ by provider: the BBC had City-Brighton at 1.92 to 1.00, Sportmonks at 2.03 to 0.98.

Predictions

Predictions

Know someone who should read this?