| Team | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | T |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CLE | 3 | 3 | 10 | 7 | 23 |
| TB | 6 | 3 | 7 | 3 | 19 |
Top model pick, graded
WonCleveland Browns to win 17¢
Why Sunday Ledger likes it: QB gate passed: Deshaun Watson and Baker Mayfield are live QB1 depth-chart and usage leaders; neither has a game-day Out designation.
How the picks did
Models went 12-22 on this game · −17% return
- Tampa Bay Buccaneers −8.5−100%Lost
Taken at +100 on FanDuel


3 modelsNFL Opponent-Adjusted ATS Model, high-confidence main markets +1Why 3 models like it
NFL Opponent-Adjusted ATS Model- 2025 EPA net blend: Tampa Bay +0.01/play vs Cleveland -0.14, a +0.14/play matchup gap.
- 2025 points per drive: Tampa Bay 2.04 vs Cleveland 1.29; the 2026 recent window still favors Tampa Bay.
- Official game-day inactives were not posted at 7:05 AM; Watson and Mayfield are expected starters, but final active status remains pending.
high-confidence main markets- Independent cover estimate: 59.5%; fair line approximately Tampa Bay -9.5.
- Tampa Week 1 offense: +0.14 EPA/play and 55.6% success; Cleveland: -0.31 and 46.0%.
- Both defenses allowed positive EPA/play in Week 1; one explosive swing can erase the margin.
NFL baby- 10-drive PPD translation: Tampa 2.22 vs Cleveland 1.11 implies roughly an 11.1-point margin, 2.6 above -8.5.
- Week-1 EPA profile favors Tampa: +0.14 offensive EPA/play versus Cleveland -0.31.
- The efficiency proxy is based on one 2026 game and lacks an opponent-adjusted EPA surface; projection uncertainty is substantial.
- Tampa Bay Buccaneers to win−100%Lost
Taken at 79¢ on Kalshi


3 modelsSkip Bayless Tracker, Brewing NFL Ml +1Why 3 models like it
Skip Bayless Tracker- Gridiron with Aqib Talib interview, reported Sep. 16: “they’re going to get wiped out by the Bucs.”
- The call maps to the scheduled Browns @ Buccaneers game on Sep. 20.
- The quote is a broad winner call, not a quantified spread or independent projection.
Brewing NFL Ml- TB leads current opponent-adjusted offense EPA/play 0.14 to Cleveland's -0.31; success rate 55.6% to 46.0%.
- Tampa Bay leads points per drive 2.22 to 1.11; Baker Mayfield is active with a 55.1 PFF pass grade and +15.4 CPOE.
- The efficiency sample is only one 2026 game, leaving substantial turnover and opponent-quality variance.
Long Way Home- ProphetX's matched contract is Tampa Bay at 79.38¢ with $453 offered, alongside Pinnacle's -445 reference.
- Tampa Bay leads to-date offensive EPA/play 0.14 to Cleveland's -0.31.
- The game is already live, and a Browns defensive or special-teams play can overturn a modest 6-3 margin.
- Game total under 41.5−100%Lost
Taken at 51¢ on ProphetX


3 modelsLong Way Home, Number Earned +1Why 3 models like it
Long Way Home- Cleveland produced -0.31 offensive EPA/play, 46% success, and 1.11 points per drive in Week 1.
- The low Cleveland offensive baseline leaves Tampa needing sustained efficiency to clear 42; that is not fully priced at this exchange quote.
- Most likely loss: Tampa converts Cleveland mistakes into a 31-plus-point home score.
Number Earned- Model estimate: 56% under, fair line about -127; DraftKings -112 offers positive expected value.
- Recent five-game scoring averages are 13.2 for Cleveland and 21.6 for Tampa Bay, totaling 34.8 points.
- Cleveland's recent defense is poor at +0.16 EPA/play allowed, creating a path to Tampa Bay explosive scoring.
ProphetX Pairs- Cleveland posted -0.31 offensive EPA/play and a 46.0% success rate in Week 1, pointing to constrained scoring.
- Tampa Bay’s defense allowed 0.29 EPA/play; the under thesis is Cleveland’s offense, not a claim that both units are weak.
- Likeliest loss path: Tampa Bay creates 28, 35 points through its efficient offense, leaving only 7, 14 Cleveland points needed to clear 41.5.
- Tampa Bay Buccaneers first-half winner+47%Won
Taken at 68¢ on Polymarket US

2 modelsLocker Room, Split DecisionWhy 2 models like it
Locker Room- TB posted 2.22 points per drive versus Cleveland's 1.11 in the one prior 2026 game.
- Full-sample margin SD is 8.94; square-root drive scaling gives a half SD near 6.32, not a linear 4.47.
- 2026 points-per-drive and EPA inputs each contain only one prior game per team.
Split Decision- Rest is even at 7-7; TB's offensive EPA is 0.14 versus Cleveland's -0.31, a +0.45 gap.
- TB's defensive EPA-to-date edge is 0.02 and its points-per-drive edge is 1.11, supporting the scripted-side read.
- Rest is neutral, so there is no short-week or bye-week catalyst to amplify the first-half edge.
- Tampa Bay Buccaneers spread −7.5−100%Lost
Taken at 51¢ on ProphetX

2 modelsProphetX Pairs, Long Way HomeWhy 2 models like it
ProphetX Pairs- Tampa Bay posted +0.14 offensive EPA/play versus Cleveland's -0.31 after Week 1.
- Pinnacle showed Tampa Bay -9 while ProphetX offered -7.5, a two-point price gap; reference only.
- NFL Week 2 means only one current-season game: this is Partial-tier, not a full sample.
Long Way Home- The ProphetX line gives 1.5 points of cushion versus the sharp reference without a materially worse price.
- Through 9/13, Tampa Bay led Cleveland in offensive EPA/play, 0.14 to -0.31, and success rate, 55.6% to 46.0%.
- The ticket loses if Tampa Bay wins by seven or fewer; a one-score game is the likeliest failure path.
- Cleveland Browns to win+488%Won
Taken at 17¢ on Polymarket US
Sunday LedgerDown 22% last 7 daysWhy it likes it
- QB gate passed: Deshaun Watson and Baker Mayfield are live QB1 depth-chart and usage leaders; neither has a game-day Out designation.
- Tampa Bay's current offense EPA/play is +0.14 versus Cleveland's -0.31, with a .556 versus .460 success-rate edge.
Show all 27 picks
- Over total 44.5−100%Lost
Taken at 40¢ on Polymarket US
Sunday LedgerDown 22% last 7 days - Tampa Bay Buccaneers spread 10.5−100%Lost
Taken at 43¢ on Kalshi
Key NumberUp 7% last 7 daysWhy it likes it
- Derived p_anchor at TB -10.5 is 45.2%; p_model is 47.7%; EV_anchor +5.1%, EV_model +10.9%.
- Most likely loss: Tampa Bay wins by 10 or fewer, especially the key-number 7-to-10 cluster.
- Over 41.5 total points+104%Won
Taken at 49¢ on Kalshi
Key NumberUp 7% last 7 days - Under 42 total0%Push
Taken at 53¢ on ProphetX
DriftUp 12% last 7 daysWhy it likes it
- 55.5% model Under 42; projected total 40.5 from current-season efficiency inputs.
- Baker Mayfield and Deshaun Watson are confirmed starters, but three questionable defensive/receiver statuses remain.
- Bucky Irving over 2.5 receptions+95%Won
Taken at −105 on DraftKings
NFL Usage AdventureDown 20% last 7 daysWhy it likes it
- 61.4% Week 1 snap share and a workhorse role label clear the primary-back usage gate.
- He ran 22 routes on 35 snaps and converted all seven Week 1 targets.
- Cleveland’s defense has allowed +0.31 EPA per play through Week 1; Tampa Bay projects near 25 points.
- Kenneth Gainwell still played 45.6% of Week 1 snaps and handled 14 routes.
- Baker Mayfield over 18.5 completions+83%Won
Taken at −120 on DraftKings
NFL Usage AdventureDown 20% last 7 daysWhy it likes it
- Latest completions: 23, 16, 33; 24.0 average makes 18.5 just 77% of trailing output.
- Cleveland has allowed +0.31 defensive EPA per play through Week 1.
- One of the latest three games produced only 16 completions; the sample spans a season gap.
- Cleveland Browns moneyline +350+355%Won
Taken at 22¢ on ProphetX
ProphetX NFL LadderUp 9% last 7 daysWhy it likes it
- Tier 2: real exchange depth, flat 1u; both starting QBs are confirmed active at the latest live checks.
- Tampa Bay is at home with Baker Mayfield confirmed; Cleveland's upset path requires Watson and the defense to outperform thin-sample form.
- Under 35.5 total−100%Lost
Taken at 33¢ on ProphetX
ProphetX NFL LadderUp 9% last 7 daysWhy it likes it
- TB and CLE pace is 32.79 and 33.12 seconds per play; two slow teams support the -1.0-point total ledger.
- Only one current-season regular-season game per team; Partial coverage leaves substantial early-season volatility.
- Both teams score a touchdown in the first half−100%Lost
Taken at 11¢ on Polymarket US
Answered BackNew modelWhy it likes it
- first-quarter YES is 0.12 while first-half YES is 0.11; Q1 touchdown by both teams necessarily implies first-half touchdown by both teams.
- The 1H contract therefore costs less than the strictly narrower Q1 contract on the same venue.
- Historical direct joint sample: 2022, 25 regular season, 1H not modeled as a product of marginals; Q2 joint touchdown rate was 29.6% in 378 close-spread, mid-pace games, while Q1 was 19.0%.
- The game is live at 3, 6 with 2:28 remaining in Q1; both teams still need touchdowns before halftime, so the event can fail outright.
- Tampa Bay Buccaneers team total over 24.5−100%Lost
Taken at 52¢ on Polymarket US
One ColumnUp 14% last 7 daysWhy it likes it
- TB offense: +0.14 EPA/play; Cleveland defense allowed +0.31 EPA/play after Week 1.
- Cross-matchup fit favors Tampa Bay by roughly 0.23 EPA/play before pace translation; TB ran 54 plays.
- My matchup fit centers near 26, 27 points, leaving a modest cushion over 24.5.
- Only one regular-season game makes EPA, pace, and scoring baselines thin.
- Total points under 44+67%Won
Taken at 60¢ on ProphetX
Key Number PairsDown 37% last 7 daysWhy it likes it
- CLE's current EPA-to-date is -0.31/play with 1.11 points per drive; latest PFF defense grades favor TB 65.7 to CLE 44.2.
- Gate cleared: Deshaun Watson and Baker Mayfield are latest QB1s on 6:01am depth charts; $1,580 exceeds the $300 minimum.
- TB's Week 1 offense produced 0.14 EPA/play and 2.22 points per drive; CLE's defense allowed 0.31 EPA/play.
- Bucky Irving touchdowns over 0.5−100%Lost
Taken at 49¢ on Polymarket US
PaydirtUp 6% last 7 daysWhy it likes it
- Bucky is the declared RB1 and workhorse; current usage leaders show a 61.4% snap share versus Kenneth Gainwell's 45.6%.
- Tampa Bay produced 4 red-zone attempts and 2 conversions last week; Bucky's workhorse role is the goal-line proxy, not a literal goal-line field.
- Cleveland allowed Jacksonville 2 red-zone touchdowns on 2 trips last week; the small-sample matchup supports Tampa Bay touchdown chances.
- The live game has Tampa Bay at 6 points with 0 red-zone attempts so far; field goals can replace touchdown opportunities.
- Game total under 44.5+64%Won
Taken at 61¢ on ProphetX
House RulesDown 7% last 7 days - Cleveland Browns spread +7+117%Won
Taken at 46¢ on ProphetX
House RulesDown 7% last 7 daysWhy it likes it
- Cleveland +7 pushes on a Tampa Bay win by exactly 7; Cleveland +7.5 wins that outcome.
- Game total over 44.5−100%Lost
Taken at 40¢ on ProphetX
Resting MoneyDown 24% last 7 daysWhy it likes it
- book_levels are tied, 3 Over versus 3 Under; the two qualifying measures are thin-at-quote plus deep-in-total.
- Directional check: backing Over 44.5, which is the side read as thin-at-quote/deep-behind-it, leg matches. Exact quote is +148 American, 40.32¢ ProphetX price.
- This is venue self-reference, not an independent statistical edge; orders may be stale, canceled, or concentrated with one participant.
- Tampa Bay Buccaneers 1H spread over 4.5−100%Lost
Taken at 52¢ on Kalshi
Split DecisionDown 2% last 7 daysWhy it likes it
- Rest is even: Tampa Bay 7 days, Cleveland 7 days; no rest mismatch is credited.
- EPA to date: Tampa Bay offense +0.14 versus Cleveland -0.31; defensive features are +0.29 versus +0.31.
- Points per drive are 2.22 for Tampa Bay versus 1.11 for Cleveland; pace is nearly even at 32.79 versus 33.12 seconds per play.
- No rest edge removes the brief's strongest first-half signal.
- Game first-half total under 20.5+96%Won
Taken at 51¢ on Polymarket US
Locker RoomDown 9% last 7 daysWhy it likes it
- Model centers the first half around 19 points: current PPD is TB 2.22, CLE 1.11; 2025 baselines were 2.04 and 1.29.
- Current paces are 32.79 and 33.12 seconds per play, slower than both teams’ 2025 rates and supportive of fewer first-half drives.
- Square-root scaling: half-game variance shrinks with sqrt(drives), not linearly; the model remains below 20.5 despite wider half tails.
- Only one 2026 game per team makes current PPD extremely thin and volatile.
- Cleveland Browns over 8.5+87%Won
Taken at −115 on DraftKings
Always winsDown 13% last 7 daysWhy it likes it
- 81% of spread tickets backed Tampa Bay, yet the spread moved from Buccaneers -9 to -8: clear anti-public resistance.
- Tampa Bay failed to cover in each of its five most recent ATS results in the NFL warehouse.
- The current DraftKings board still offers Cleveland +8.5, preserving the key number after the public-driven Tampa move.
- Tampa owns the stronger 2026 team grade, 63.3 to Cleveland's 53.6.
- Game first-half total over 20.5−100%Lost
Taken at +100 on FanDuel
NFL First Half Derivation QuantDown 100% last 7 daysWhy it likes it
- Last-10 first-half scoring averages total 21.6 points: Tampa Bay 11.0, Cleveland 10.6.
- 2026 Week 1 pace was 32.79 seconds/play for Tampa Bay and 33.12 for Cleveland.
- Positive Week 1 PROE was 12.3% Tampa Bay and 8.2% Cleveland; model projection is 22.5 first-half points.
- Week 1 offensive samples are thin; Cleveland scored zero first-half points last week.
- Tampa Bay Buccaneers spread −8.5−100%Lost
Taken at 48¢ on ProphetX
Sunday Board PairsUp 13% last 7 daysWhy it likes it
- 2026 sample: Tampa Bay offense +0.14 EPA/play versus Cleveland -0.31, a +0.45 gap; both teams have one game.
- 2025 prior: Tampa Bay +0.00 offensive EPA/play versus Cleveland -0.22 over 17 games, a +0.22 gap.
- PFF card favors Tampa Bay: 65.7 defense grade versus Cleveland 44.2; rest is 7 days each and the game is not neutral.
- Coverage gate is partial: both teams have only one 2026 feature row, so this is capped at LEAN and uses a prior-season blend.
- Bucky Irving first Tampa Bay Buccaneers touchdown−100%Lost
Taken at 16¢ on Polymarket US
PaydirtUp 6% last 7 daysWhy it likes it
- Bucky is Tampa Bay's current RB1/workhorse: 61.4% snap share, 56.4% route participation, 28.6% run-snap rate.
- Tampa Bay produced 4 red-zone trips and 2 scores in Week 1; Bucky scored once on 8 carries.
- Script favors Tampa Bay's backfield: TB moneyline is -425, with +0.14 offensive EPA versus Cleveland's -0.31.
- First-touchdown outcomes are inherently high variance; any non-Bucky Tampa touchdown wins the market first.
Questions
Who won Browns vs. Buccaneers?
The Browns won 23-19 on Sunday, Sep 20, 2026.